First Team
Taylor Totland - (2010-13): The most decorated girls golfer in Shore Conference over the past decade, Totland was a force from the moment she stepped onto the course as a freshman, winning four Monmouth County Tournaments, three Shore Conference Tournaments and the individual title at the NJSIAA Tournament of Champions in 2012, finishing second in that event in 2011 and 2013. She went on to star at Furman, before playing professionally on the Symetra Tour.
Nicole Totland - (2013-16): Following the path blazed by her older sister, Nicole helped the Caseys achieve unequaled heights when they took the team title at the 2016 NJSIAA Tournament of Champions. Along the way she won three Monmouth County Tournaments and two Shore Conference Tournament titles. She also finished fourth at the 2014 Tournament of Champions.
Second Team
Ariana Palmieri